Skip to content
DULUTH, MINNESOTA
Howie

Duluth's homegrown columnist. Since 1971.

Duluth Politics
Duluth Mayor Roger Reinert. Howie / HowieHanson.com

Duluth’s next mayoral election belongs to nobody

The organized left has demonstrated that it can win consequential local elections. It has not demonstrated that an unnamed candidate can defeat Reinert citywide.

Howie Hanson

Howie

Editor & Publisher

6-minute read

Mayor Roger Reinert knows better than most that a landslide in Duluth comes with an expiration date. He delivered the last one.

In 2023, Reinert blitzed Mayor Emily Larson by 5,802 votes, winning nearly 60% against an incumbent who had twice won the office comfortably. It was a substantial rejection of another Larson term and a substantial investment of public confidence in Reinert.

It was not a four-year advance purchase of his reelection.

That distinction belongs at the center of every serious discussion about Duluth’s 2027 mayoral election. So does another: The organized left has demonstrated that it can win consequential local elections. It has not demonstrated that an unnamed candidate can defeat Reinert citywide.

Anyone declaring this race settled in either direction is selling certainty the evidence does not support.

Reinert has not given voters a final answer about his own plans in the reporting reviewed for this column. At his September news conference, he said he expected to consider his political future over the holidays and address it in early January.

We should take that statement as his stated timetable. We should not convert it into an invented story about fear, private polling or a decision already made.

But we can examine the landscape he faces.

Larson won 71.94% in 2015, 63.65% in 2019 and 39.99% in 2023. That is a remarkable reminder of how little yesterday’s mandate guarantees tomorrow’s consent.

Her defeat also came in a much larger mayoral electorate. Votes recorded for mayor rose from 20,959 in 2019 to 29,295 in 2023, an increase of nearly 40%. Larson’s own total fell from 13,340 to 11,716.

Those numbers undermine the easy assumption that a bigger turnout automatically helps the more progressive candidate.

They do not establish an automatic advantage for Reinert, either. Additional voters have preferences. Turnout has no ideology of its own.

The precinct returns reveal how broad his 2023 victory was, and where it stopped.

Aggregating the mayoral returns by council district, Reinert received approximately 58% of the two-candidate vote in District 1, 48% in District 2, 47% in District 3, 70% in District 4 and 72% in District 5. Those percentages exclude write-ins.

He carried every precinct in Districts 1, 4 and 5. Larson carried Districts 2 and 3 overall. That is an electoral record worth respecting. It is not a current approval survey.

Nor are Larson’s former voters a transferable asset belonging to the Democratic Socialists of America. They voted for a particular mayor against a particular challenger. A different candidate would have to earn a separate judgment.

Reinert’s political experience makes it reasonable to assume he understands that distinction. He has served on the City Council and in both chambers of the Minnesota Legislature. He has seen politics from more than one office and more than one constituency.

What he privately concludes about his chances remains unknown.

My judgment is that he would enter a reelection campaign as a serious contender with demonstrated citywide reach. There is insufficient evidence to attach responsible numerical odds, much less declare him safe or doomed. His greatest change in circumstances is obvious: He now owns a mayoral record.

In 2023, voters could judge the promise of his administration. In 2027, they can judge its performance.

The administration’s March State of the City summary reported 799 new housing units among its 2025 accomplishments, along with 36 miles of street construction, rehabilitation and preservation, and 2,400 lead-service replacements.

Those figures deserve scrutiny and fair credit. They should not be dismissed because they come from an incumbent, or accepted as proof that one mayor personally produced every result. Public projects often involve earlier planning, outside funding, council decisions and years of work.

The questions are practical. Are homes becoming more attainable? Are streets improving at a pace residents can see? Is downtown becoming more functional? Is the city financing maintenance or postponing another bill?

Reinert’s emphasis on property-tax restraint is equally legitimate to examine. The city described its September maximum-levy action as a 2.65% effective increase for the city portion in 2027, with final budget adoption still ahead in December.

That does not describe every household’s entire tax bill.

And a restrained levy, standing alone, does not establish sound management. The accompanying question is whether the city can maintain dependable services and meet its obligations over time. Voters deserve both halves of that accounting.

They deserve the same discipline when considering a challenger from the organized left.

DSA is an organization, not a separate ballot party. An endorsement tells voters something meaningful about a political relationship. It does not relieve journalists of establishing what the candidate actually proposes.

Twin Ports DSA’s published activities include housing work, environmental organizing, mutual aid and electoral participation. Those priorities raise legitimate questions about affordability, public resources and whose concerns receive attention. They also require answers about cost, authority, implementation and competing needs.

A housing promise needs financing. An environmental position needs a clear explanation of its consequences. A proposal to expand services needs dependable revenue and the administrative capacity to deliver.

Good intentions deserve a hearing. They do not substitute for a budget.

Recent results make it equally unreasonable to dismiss the organized left as irrelevant.

DSA-backed Kris Eilers defeated incumbent Annie Harala for a St. Louis County Board seat this month, 5,788–4,971. That is evidence of a successful candidate and an effective campaign in that district. It is not a citywide mayoral forecast.

The 2025 tenant right-to-repair vote provides another important lesson. Duluth voters approved the measure with nearly 69% support after the City Council had rejected the petition ordinance. Residents can support a specific tenant protection by a large margin without signing on to an entire ideological program.

They can also elect Reinert in one election and support such a measure in another. There is no contradiction that requires explaining away. The contradiction exists only if we insist that every voter belongs permanently in one political box.

If Reinert does not run, the election changes substantially. Yes, there could be a crowded contest. An open office can attract people who would hesitate to challenge a sitting mayor. Experienced elected officials, civic figures and newcomers could see an opportunity.

But a free-for-all is a possibility, not an established candidate list.

Duluth’s nonpartisan process would narrow a contested mayoral primary to two finalists. The statewide election calendar lists Aug. 10 for the 2027 primary and Nov. 2 for the general election.

An open race would also change the central question. Instead of deciding whether to renew Reinert’s tenure, voters would compare competing claims to succeed him.

His 2023 coalition would not automatically transfer to a preferred successor. Neither would dissatisfaction with his administration automatically unite behind a DSA-backed candidate.

An endorsement is a recommendation. Voters still make the hiring decision.

The last open mayoral election offers a useful corrective to predictions of inevitable chaos. In 2015, after Don Ness chose not to seek another term, Larson won nearly 72% in November. An open field can ultimately produce a decisive result.

Duluth needs a demanding election, whether Reinert participates or not. Demanding about numbers. Demanding about promises. Demanding about the difference between a plan and an announcement, between a completed project and a political claim.

An incumbent should not receive another term merely because the alternative carries a label some voters dislike. A challenger should not receive one merely because frustration is available.

Reinert’s victory over Larson demonstrated that Duluth voters can withdraw their confidence from a mayor who once appeared secure. The next election will test who has earned it now.

Read More

LATEST POSTS

Duluth Mayor Roger Reinert. Howie / HowieHanson.com

Duluth’s next mayoral race could test Reinert and the organized left

For now, there is no publicly established Reinert-versus-DSA matchup. There is an incumbent considering his future and an organized left with electoral successes that could help support a substantial challenge. That is enough to make the coming months important.

Howie / HowieHanson.com

Downtown Duluth takes small steps toward a bigger test

Downtown’s organizers have taken some baby steps worth acknowledging. Now comes the work of making progress visible, measurable and durable. A five-year plan deserves time to succeed, and the public deserves a clear account of what that time is producing.

The R/V Neil Armstrong, operated by the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution (WHOI), is a 238-foot research vessel equipped to support scientific missions in challenging environments. The ship departed its home port in Woods Hole, Mass. On October 28 for its first-ever voyage through the Great Lakes to help deploy underwater detectors for a neutrino research project in Lake Superior. (Photo by Chris Griner, ©Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution)

Research ship bound for Duluth to help turn Lake Superior into particle detector

The undertaking combines particle physics with the practical challenges of moving heavy scientific equipment through unfamiliar waterways. Kent Sheasley, one of the ship’s captains, said preparations include accounting for freshwater buoyancy, narrow passages, wave conditions and regional weather.

Quote Me, Howie; Klobuchar's campaign promises

On taxes, Klobuchar pledged not to increase them and said she would like to lower them. That commitment belongs prominently in the public record. A fair assessment should examine the full package of taxes and fees proposed by her administration, along with its spending choices.

Opinion: My 2026 state and local election picks held up

I picked Grant Hauschild to survive his Senate District 3 rematch against Andrea Zupancich and Aaron Schweiger to defeat Republican incumbent Natalie Zeleznikar in House District 3B. In the St. Louis County Board’s District 1 race, I gave Kris Eilers the edge over Annie Harala.

Minnesota Power seeks rate increase

DULUTH — Minnesota Power asked state regulators Monday to approve a rate increase that would raise the average residential customer’s monthly electric bill by about $24, citing higher operating costs,

Saturday News Notebook

DULUTH Three people were hospitalized, including a 69-year-old woman with serious injuries, after a St. Louis County sheriff's deputy responding to a house fire rear-ended

The local decision remained unresolved after protesters disrupted the City Council’s meeting on Monday night, prompting officials to postpone scheduled votes. The city subsequently canceled tonight's replacement meeting because of concerns about overlapping with early voting at City Hall.

Howie: Inside Hermantown’s data center proposal, the decisions extend beyond City Hall

HERMANTOWN — Google’s proposed data center would bring a large new taxpayer and a major electricity customer to northeastern Minnesota. Whether it is built, under what conditions and with what

The St. Louis County Board has proclaimed Nov. 4-11 as a week to honor veterans and current servicemembers by displaying a green light or lights as a show of support. During the same meeting, commissioners uanimously approved a resolution of support for the 148th Fighter Wing to be selected to receive the F-35 Lightning II mission. Submitted, St. Louis County

County Board passes resolution of support for 148th Fighter Wing

By Dana Kazel The St. Louis County Board has issued a resolution expressing its strong support for the Minnesota National Guard 148th Fighter Wing to be selected to receive the