Skip to content
DULUTH, MINNESOTA
Opinion

Minnesota Housing has an opportunity next month to help change the future of downtown Duluth, reshape the community's response to homelessness and give 40 vulnerable adults something many have struggled for years to find: a permanent place to call home.

The state agency should seize it.

The proposed Mission Heights development, an ambitious partnership between the Duluth Housing and Redevelopment Authority and Union Gospel Mission, represents far more than another government-assisted housing project. It offers a thoughtful, coordinated and financially credible approach to one of Duluth's most persistent humanitarian and economic challenges.

And perhaps most importantly, it offers a plan that could actually work.

The Minnesota Housing board is expected to consider its 2026 multifamily funding recommendations Dec. 17. Among the projects seeking support is the 40-unit permanent supportive housing component of Mission Heights, proposed for 313 W. Second St., across from the St. Louis County Government Services Center.

The decision carries enormous consequences for a community that has spent years struggling to address homelessness while simultaneously attempting to revitalize its downtown business district.

The project deserves approval.

Jill Keppers, Executive Director of the Duluth HRA, has outlined a development that goes well beyond the traditional approach of offering temporary shelter, food assistance and referrals to other agencies.

The proposed three-story building would house 40 efficiency apartments on its upper two floors, replacing and expanding upon the 20 single-room occupancy units now available at Union Gospel Mission's existing First Street location.

These would be permanent apartments, not temporary shelter beds or dormitory-style accommodations. The difference matters enormously to people attempting to establish stability in their lives.

The first floor would become the Mission Engagement Center, a comprehensive facility combining a warming center, daytime drop-in services, meals, showers, laundry, health services, essential supplies and Union Gospel Mission offices.

Instead of sending people experiencing homelessness from one location to another in search of basic necessities, the development would concentrate critical services within a coordinated downtown network.

"First and foremost, this project is extremely important as we address the homeless response system in Duluth," Keppers said.

Her assessment goes directly to the heart of the proposal.

Duluth does not simply need more places where people experiencing homelessness can spend another night. It needs a stronger system for helping them transition out of homelessness altogether.

That is precisely what Mission Heights is designed to advance.

Union Gospel Mission, CHUM and the Damiano Center have been working together through the Stepping On Up initiative to establish a coordinated pathway from homelessness to permanent housing. Their collective approach recognizes that effective intervention requires emergency assistance, professional services, housing opportunities and sustained follow-through.

"This development is critical to make that plan a reality," Keppers said.

Those are powerful words from the director of the public housing authority responsible for helping bring the development together.

They also explain why Minnesota Housing's upcoming decision is so important.

The HRA is directing development of the overall project, according to Keppers, and will own the first-floor engagement center. The state Legislature awarded $8.85 million in general obligation bonding for that component during its 2026 session, providing a major financial foundation for construction.

Because general obligation bond financing requires public ownership, the HRA plans to retain ownership of the first floor and lease it to Union Gospel Mission for approximately $1 annually under a long-term agreement.

That arrangement would keep the publicly financed property under public ownership while allowing an experienced nonprofit organization to operate the services.

"We are very thankful to our Duluth delegation for their unwavering support of this much needed project," Keppers said.

The delegation deserves that recognition.

In an era when government funding is frequently criticized, its support for Mission Heights represents the kind of targeted public investment that can address a genuine community need while creating the possibility of long-term benefits.

Essentia Health has also committed $500,000 toward the new center, while Duluth city officials have conditionally committed $400,000 in future federal housing funds toward the residential component.

The development has received substantial backing from public agencies, nonprofit organizations and community partners.

But the financing remains unfinished.

The approximately $10.4 million engagement center has secured its anticipated funding, according to HRA officials. The approximately $20 million residential portion remains dependent on additional financing, including the application awaiting Minnesota Housing's December decision.

The preferred financing arrangement, Keppers explained, would use Housing Infrastructure Bonds to fund the apartments, allowing Union Gospel Mission to own the upper floors.

An alternative would combine those bonds with 4% federal Low-Income Housing Tax Credits. Under that structure, the HRA and Union Gospel Mission would serve as general partners, with a tax-credit investor participating as a limited partner.

The HRA would anticipate eventually withdrawing from the general partnership, potentially after approximately five to seven years.

Professional management is also part of the plan. Keppers said Van Rooy Property Management, which manages Duluth's Harbor Highlands properties, is expected to oversee the apartments and help ensure compliance with financing and regulatory requirements.

These are not minor details.

They demonstrate that Mission Heights is being approached as a serious housing development with an identifiable ownership structure, experienced partners and long-term management expectations.

Minnesota Housing should consider that preparation carefully.

But there is another compelling reason for supporting the development, one that should command attention from everyone concerned about the economic future of Duluth.

Mission Heights could become a catalyst for downtown redevelopment.

Union Gospel Mission's relocation from its existing First Street location would bring its operations closer to CHUM and the Damiano Center, creating a more convenient concentration of services for people who currently must navigate downtown to meet basic needs.

Keppers believes that improved coordination could reduce unnecessary pedestrian travel between service locations and provide more appropriate places for people to gather.

The proposed engagement center would include private outdoor gathering space, offering a more dignified alternative to congregating on public sidewalks.

That could benefit both the people receiving services and the surrounding downtown neighborhood.

The relocation would also create opportunities to rethink the future of the First Street corridor, where the Mission has operated for decades.

Downtown Duluth desperately needs additional investment, housing, commercial activity and reasons for private developers to believe in its long-term prospects.

A redevelopment strategy that addresses homelessness while creating new possibilities for vacant or underused properties deserves serious consideration.

The problems facing downtown are not exclusively economic, nor are they exclusively humanitarian.

They are connected.

A successful downtown must be welcoming to residents, visitors, workers and business owners. It also must acknowledge that people experiencing homelessness are members of the community who deserve safety, dignity and meaningful opportunities to rebuild their lives.

Those objectives are not mutually exclusive.

Mission Heights offers the possibility of advancing both.

There is another dimension to the proposal that has received too little public attention.

Keppers said the new engagement center would create a second warming-center option in Duluth, allowing providers to better accommodate people with different circumstances and needs.

The Mission Engagement Center would operate under what Keppers described as a "harm reduction model" for overnight winter warming. The existing Lincoln Park warming center would transition toward a "dry site," intended to be more accommodating to families and people in recovery.

The distinction is important.

People experiencing homelessness do not all have the same needs. Some are navigating substance use disorders, some are working toward recovery, some have families and others face serious behavioral health or medical challenges.

A community that offers only one type of emergency accommodation risks excluding people who cannot safely or comfortably use it.

Two differently structured facilities could provide more appropriate options while allowing service providers to direct people toward the environment best suited to their circumstances.

That is not an argument for abandoning expectations of responsible behavior, safety or accountability.

It is an argument for recognizing that effective homelessness intervention requires more than a single solution.

The proposed arrangement would need careful operating standards, capable management and ongoing evaluation. But the underlying strategy is sensible and worthy of investment.

Duluth has spent too many years responding to homelessness as a collection of individual emergencies rather than as a communitywide challenge requiring coordinated action.

Police officers cannot solve it alone. Emergency departments cannot solve it alone. Downtown merchants cannot solve it alone. Neither can individual churches, nonprofits or government agencies.

The answer requires cooperation among organizations with different responsibilities and areas of expertise.

Mission Heights represents exactly that kind of partnership.

There are, of course, legitimate questions surrounding any development involving tens of millions of dollars in public and private financing.

The community deserves transparency about construction costs, ongoing operating expenses, property management, safety procedures and the effectiveness of supportive services.

It deserves regular reporting on how many people obtain housing, how many remain housed and whether the development is achieving its stated objectives.

And downtown businesses and neighboring property owners deserve meaningful opportunities to participate in discussions about the surrounding neighborhood.

Supporting Mission Heights should not mean writing a blank check.

It should mean insisting that a promising development receive both the investment and the oversight necessary to succeed.

It is also important to recognize that 40 apartments, however valuable, will not eliminate homelessness in Duluth.

The city's 2025 comprehensive housing study identified a need for 2,094 additional affordable housing units by 2030.

Mission Heights would address only a small portion of that shortage.

But numbers can obscure the human significance of what is being proposed.

Forty apartments mean 40 opportunities for people to have their own doors, their own kitchens, their own bathrooms and the stability necessary to begin rebuilding their lives.

For individuals who have endured the uncertainty of temporary shelters, unstable accommodations or life without a home, that represents an extraordinary change.

And for a city trying to address the visible consequences of homelessness, permanent housing with ongoing support represents a more promising long-term strategy than repeatedly managing emergencies.

Mission Heights previously failed to secure the necessary state housing financing. That disappointment makes the December decision especially significant.

Minnesota Housing faces a competitive funding process, with worthy developments across the state seeking limited resources. Every application must be evaluated fairly and according to established standards.

But Mission Heights brings a persuasive combination of factors to that process: demonstrated community need, substantial state bonding support, an experienced public housing authority, an established nonprofit service provider, additional local and private commitments, and a coordinated strategy for improving homelessness services.

The project also connects two important public objectives that are too often considered separately: housing stability and downtown revitalization.

If the final financing can be assembled, construction is envisioned in 2027, with the completed facility opening in 2028.

Imagine what that could mean.

A modern service center providing meals, health care, hygiene facilities, emergency warming and coordinated support. Forty permanent apartments immediately above those services. A more convenient network connecting Union Gospel Mission, CHUM and the Damiano Center.

A new opportunity for redevelopment along First Street. More appropriate gathering space. And a more organized system designed to move people from homelessness into housing.

None of these improvements is guaranteed simply by constructing a building. Success will require sustained commitment from the organizations involved and the community supporting them.

But Duluth rarely gets an opportunity to advance so many interconnected priorities through a single development.

Minnesota Housing should recognize the significance of that opportunity.

In the end, the December decision is about more than financing 40 apartments.

It is about whether Duluth can move beyond managing homelessness and begin building a more coordinated system for reducing it.

It is about whether public investment can contribute to both human dignity and downtown economic recovery.

And it is about whether a coalition of organizations that has done the difficult work of developing a credible plan will receive the state support necessary to move forward.

The Duluth HRA, Union Gospel Mission and their partners have assembled much of the foundation. State lawmakers have already made a substantial commitment to the engagement center. Local government and private contributors have joined the effort.

Now Minnesota Housing has an opportunity to help complete the picture.

Approve the Mission Heights housing financing. Help Duluth build all three floors, not just the first.

The state has already helped provide the foundation.

Now it should help put the homes above it.

Read More

QUOTE ME, HOWIE

I truly believe that the political left is much more fiscally responsible than what is deemed the center, and that is because we're focused on bread-and-butter issues and quality of life.

— St. Louis County Commissioner Ashley Grimm

LATEST POSTS

Howie / HowieHanson.com

Downtown Duluth takes small steps toward a bigger test

Downtown’s organizers have taken some baby steps worth acknowledging. Now comes the work of making progress visible, measurable and durable. A five-year plan deserves time to succeed, and the public deserves a clear account of what that time is producing.

The R/V Neil Armstrong, operated by the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution (WHOI), is a 238-foot research vessel equipped to support scientific missions in challenging environments. The ship departed its home port in Woods Hole, Mass. On October 28 for its first-ever voyage through the Great Lakes to help deploy underwater detectors for a neutrino research project in Lake Superior. (Photo by Chris Griner, ©Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution)

Research ship bound for Duluth to help turn Lake Superior into particle detector

The undertaking combines particle physics with the practical challenges of moving heavy scientific equipment through unfamiliar waterways. Kent Sheasley, one of the ship’s captains, said preparations include accounting for freshwater buoyancy, narrow passages, wave conditions and regional weather.

Quote Me, Howie; Klobuchar's campaign promises

On taxes, Klobuchar pledged not to increase them and said she would like to lower them. That commitment belongs prominently in the public record. A fair assessment should examine the full package of taxes and fees proposed by her administration, along with its spending choices.

Opinion: My 2026 state and local election picks held up

I picked Grant Hauschild to survive his Senate District 3 rematch against Andrea Zupancich and Aaron Schweiger to defeat Republican incumbent Natalie Zeleznikar in House District 3B. In the St. Louis County Board’s District 1 race, I gave Kris Eilers the edge over Annie Harala.

Minnesota Power seeks rate increase

DULUTH — Minnesota Power asked state regulators Monday to approve a rate increase that would raise the average residential customer’s monthly electric bill by about $24, citing higher operating costs,

Saturday News Notebook

DULUTH Three people were hospitalized, including a 69-year-old woman with serious injuries, after a St. Louis County sheriff's deputy responding to a house fire rear-ended